🏡 Property Analysis Report

742 Evergreen Terrace, Springfield, IL 62701 | Generated: April 1, 2026 | Goal: Buy & Hold Rental

Overall Verdict

✅ STRONG BUY — Underpriced relative to comps. Solid rental yield.

This property is priced 7% below comparable recent sales and offers a projected gross rental yield of 8.2%. Days on market (47) suggest negotiation leverage. Recommend offering $238,000–$242,000.

Listing Overview

List Price	$249,000
Property Type	Single Family Home
Beds / Baths	3 bed / 2 bath
Square Footage	1,820 sqft
Price / sqft	$136.81
Year Built	1987
Lot Size	0.22 acres
Days on Market	47 days ⚠️
Last Price Reduction	-$10,000 (21 days ago)
Listing Source	Zillow Listing ↗

Comparable Sales (Last 90 Days, within 0.5mi)

810 Maple Ave — 3bd/2ba, 1,790 sqft | Sold: $265,000 ($148/sqft) | 22 days ago

34 Oak St — 3bd/2ba, 1,850 sqft | Sold: $258,500 ($139/sqft) | 41 days ago

509 Elm Blvd — 3bd/1.5ba, 1,700 sqft | Sold: $241,000 ($141/sqft) | 67 days ago

📊 Avg comp price/sqft: $142.67 | Implied fair value: ~$259,659 | Current list is 4.1% below fair value

Total Cost of Ownership (Est. Monthly)

Mortgage (20% down, 6.8% rate, 30yr)	$1,301/mo
Property Tax (est.)	$248/mo
Homeowner's Insurance (est.)	$95/mo
Maintenance Reserve (1% of value/yr)	$207/mo
Total Est. Monthly Cost	$1,851/mo

Rental Income Analysis

Est. Market Rent	$1,700/mo
Annual Gross Rent	$20,400
Gross Rental Yield	8.2% ✅
Est. Net Yield (after expenses)	~5.4%
Monthly Cash Flow (est.)	-$151/mo (slight negative — plan for appreciation)

Note: Yield is strong for this market. Slight negative monthly cash flow typical for buy-and-hold in this zip at current rates.

Neighborhood Intelligence

Walk Score	61 — Somewhat Walkable
Transit Score	42 — Some Transit
Bike Score	55 — Bikeable
School District	Springfield USD 419
GreatSchools Rating	7/10 ✅
1-Year Appreciation (zip)	+4.1%
3-Year Appreciation (zip)	+14.8%
5-Year Appreciation (zip)	+31.2%

Risk & Inspection Flags

✅ Not in FEMA Flood Zone ✅ Low wildfire risk ⚠️ Built 1987 — likely original HVAC (service due) ⚠️ 47 days on market — inspect thoroughly for hidden defects ✅ No HOA ✅ Property tax trend stable (+2.1%/yr over 3yrs) ⚠️ Roof age unknown — request disclosure

Offer Strategy

Recommended Offer Range	$238,000 – $242,000
Reasoning	47 DOM + recent reduction = motivated seller. 4.1% below comps gives room to negotiate.
Inspection Contingency	Yes — strongly recommended (1987 build)
Financing Contingency	Yes
Escalation Clause	Not recommended — no competing offers detected
Best Use	Buy & Hold Rental / Owner-Occupy

Client-Ready Summary

742 Evergreen Terrace is priced below comparable recent sales in the area and has been on the market 47 days following a $10,000 price reduction — a strong signal of seller motivation. The neighborhood shows consistent appreciation trends and a solid school district rating. For a buy-and-hold investor, the gross rental yield of 8.2% is competitive for this market, though expect modest negative monthly cash flow at current interest rates. I recommend an offer in the $238,000–$242,000 range with standard inspection and financing contingencies. Request HVAC service records and roof age disclosure during inspection.

Analyze Your Property →

This report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or real estate advice. Data sourced from public records. Verify all figures independently before transacting.